Ranks- Male- Female Piano round – 8th June 2007

Ranks- Male- Female Piano round – 8th June 2007


Emon – 8/10

Bijuria; most happening n evergreen song of sonu nigam. N Emon did a great job. But it’s true , he tries songs of sonu nigam only, he should try some other ranges as well. But I truly njoyed his singing n performance.

Charu – 8.5/10
I listen n re-listen to this lovely lady voice. I think one of the mature female singer of Indian dio. N she really took my heart away with this song. Very beautifully sung and very very melodious voice.

Smita – 7/10
I think smita tried to repeat her zubi zubi performance; she should try some other songs. She did a good job with it’s the time to dosco, but personally I felt it was ok.

Parleen – 8/10
This is one of my personal very fav song .. very romantic number from the movie Gangster and I was lost when Parleen was singing.

Deepali – 7.5/10
Deepali is a very good singer and got an unique voice. But somehow there ws something lacking..

Suhit – 5.5/10
He was flat in many places. I did not n’joyed. Just my personal opinion.

Abhishek – 8.5/10
Wow.. amazing singing.. mind blowing.. I loved it.. again sonu nigam song but I loved it.

Prashant – 8/10
If I m not wrong, this is Kishore Da song; and Kishore da songs are always diff to sing. Prashant sang this song in his own style and I loved his singing. Dunno why judges don’t praise him tht much. But I liked his voice quality as well as singing.

Puja – 7.5/10
Puja, a very good and versatile singer.. but she needs some polishing and years to reach that stage. She is a gem and really can be a very good singer one day like Sunidhi Chauhan.

Chang – 7/10
Dunno, I did not liked his perf. His voice really suited on soft romantic number. No doubt his perf was better than the last one but not as good as his second piano round.

Richa – 6/10
Tday Richa seems very sad and it was clearly noticed that her voice needed many years to come to that level of other singers.

Ankita – 5.5/10
Her Performance is always good but she never impresses me with her singing. She always chooses a same style of singing.


These are my personal comments.

http://www.creative-castle.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=2238